August 25, 2017
The President of the United States
1600 Pennsylvania Ave.
Washington, DC 20500
Dear Mister President:
I learn today that you have pardoned Joseph Arpaio, former Sheriff of Maricopa County, Arizona, for his conviction related to violations of citizens’ civil rights in defiance of federal court orders.
Further, I learn today that you have issued a directive to the Defense Department which will ban transgender persons from serving in the United States Armed Forces.
And, of course, I have listened to your words and your tone over the last two weeks since white supremacists marched in Charlottesville, Virginia, and one of them killed a young woman. Your initial response made a false equivalence between people attempting to preserve their civil rights and people who seek to take those rights away from them. Your second response clearly condemned the racist and violent agenda of white supremacy. It was late, but it was clear. But the very next day you returned to that false equivalency again.
Let me be clear with this, sir: there are no two sides between those who would dominate and those resisting domination. We are not talking about plain bigotry. We are talking about who makes choices for other people. The white supremacists claim that they should make the decisions which impact those of darker skins, or who are women, or who find love differently than they.
They are wrong. They should not. And you should not encourage them as you did last week in Phoenix, as you have done today with the pardon for Mr. Arpaio, and as you have done today with a ban on transgender persons.
Fortunately, there is a remedy for this. It is called repentance, and it is an ancient religious tradition. Here’s how it works:
You acknowledge the wrong.
You apologize for the wrong.
You do what can be done to undo the wrong. Now, you can’t revoke the pardon for Mr. Arpaio, but you can clearly order ICE agents to refrain from the racial profiling activity Mr. Arpaio engaged in.
And you strive never to do that wrong again.
Sir, you owe it to the American people. We need to see that you serve all America’s citizens, and not just those with light skin.
If you cannot, there is another remedy. It’s also very simple. It goes like this:
You address a letter to the Secretary of State, which reads:
“I resign the office of President of the United States.”
Because, sir, if you cannot apologize for these words and actions, you should not hold this office.
Peace to you,